Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

Current Rating in Google: 5 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Anna Roberts

September 21, 2019

My favorite jewelry shop in Florida! Excellent selection from classic, high grade diamonds to Art Deco antiquities. Love there special events and estate showcases. Staff is professional, friendly and always happy to take time to share history of their pieces and extensive expertise. Owners travel world looking for best quality and it shows! Don’t forget to fill out a wish list card!

Lorraine Maxfield

September 20, 2019

The staff at John Michael Mathews are great! So helpful and friendly. The beautiful jewelry makes it hard to choose just one item!! I love going back!

K Fredrick

July 12, 2019

I found John Michael Matthews Fine Jewelers 30 years ago when I was looking for a jeweler to combine two heirloom diamonds into a custom designed ring. I had spoken to over a dozen jewelers without success. Each of the previous jewelers wanted to show me molds, which were clearly not custom. JOhn listened carefully and promptly drew the perfect design for me. They are far superior to the other jewelers I had consulted. When I need a high quality jeweler, I always go to John Michael Matthews Jewelers. I have never been disappointed.

Carolyn Butler Norton, Esq.

September 24, 2019

My "to go" place for all my jewelry needs, including purchases, new designs, and repairs. The staff is very knowledgeable and pleasant. It's always a pleasure to visit this store!

Jan von Stein

September 20, 2019

My favorite jewelry has come from John Michael Matthews Fine Jewelry.Victoria is extremely talented and knows how to update each piece. I always have on parts of her creations!