Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

Current Rating in Google: 5 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Mary Pergiovanni

June 9, 2020

I lost one of a favorite pair of small hoop earrings. Dang! Searching online didn’t yield a replacement. Deciding to look for a jewelry store near me, I found John Michael Mathews in Vero Beach—all ‘5-star’ reviews! Called and explained my problem to Gail. She was lovely! Since stores were just reopening, she offered to email me some catalog pages if I didn’t want to risk coming out. She said that if I liked something, she would order it and then if I didn’t like it, I was under no obligation to buy. This is within 30 seconds of dialing the phone! I did go there and also met Victoria, who is the jeweler. The store had lots of lovely selections and also beautiful estate jewelry. The women found me several beautiful choices and I found a pair that really suited me. The only hard part was deciding, because I liked several. Gail and Victoria’s attitude is so friendly and they are beyond helpful. They are very kind people; I feel I really lucked out finding this place and recommend it highly.

Ed Behnke

December 3, 2019

The staff is absolutely amazing and very personable. I had a great time trying on and admiring jewelry that I would not have been in my jewelry collection. John Michael Matthews has a wonderful collection of different types of jewelry. They also will inspect and repair jewelry of all types. They advised me that I needed to have a weak link repaired on a necklace and the prongs replaced on my engagement ring. The owners and staff are the best on the business.

Suzanne Leffew

January 23, 2020

I absolutely loved working with Gail to design a new ring for me. She was able to figure out exactly what I wanted and was always very pleasant. Taylor was also extremely helpful and always had a smile on her face. What a delightful company!

Kathryn Radecke

October 16, 2019

They always have gorgeous collections on display that will cater to almost any style or occasion. What we truly love, is their design and customization ability. Victoria is an artist. She helped my husband design the most beautiful wedding ring, helped me update his ring (which also belonged to his father & grandfather), & designed a hammered gold and diamond pendant from a collection of family jewelry. They're unique and stunning items! There is no limit to her capability to turn an idea into a reality. The entire team is kind and fully invested in getting to know their clients. You won't be disappointed.

Kelly White

June 9, 2020

Best jeweler in this area. Very professional and great selection of jewelry.